File: C:/Users/fred/.codex/.tmp/plugins/plugins/plugin-eval/src/core/scoring.js
const SEVERITY_WEIGHT = {
error: 14,
warning: 6,
info: 1,
};
const STATUS_MULTIPLIER = {
fail: 1,
warn: 0.75,
info: 0.25,
pass: 0,
};
const GRADE_THRESHOLDS = {
A: 93,
B: 85,
C: 70,
D: 55,
};
const CATEGORY_PRIORITY = {
manifest: 0,
"skill-structure": 1,
budget: 2,
measurement: 3,
"best-practice": 4,
complexity: 5,
readability: 6,
"code-quality": 7,
};
const STATUS_PRIORITY = {
fail: 0,
warn: 1,
info: 2,
pass: 3,
};
function unique(items) {
return [...new Set(items.filter(Boolean))];
}
export function summarizeChecks(checks) {
return checks.reduce(
(summary, check) => {
summary.total += 1;
summary[check.status] = (summary[check.status] || 0) + 1;
summary[check.severity] = (summary[check.severity] || 0) + 1;
return summary;
},
{
total: 0,
pass: 0,
warn: 0,
fail: 0,
info: 0,
error: 0,
warning: 0,
},
);
}
function computeCheckPenalty(check) {
const weight = SEVERITY_WEIGHT[check.severity] ?? 0;
const multiplier = STATUS_MULTIPLIER[check.status] ?? 0;
return weight * multiplier;
}
function deriveCheckWhy(check) {
if (check.why) {
return check.why;
}
if (check.category === "manifest") {
return "Manifest issues reduce trust because Codex may not discover or represent the plugin correctly.";
}
if (check.category === "skill-structure") {
return "Skill structure issues reduce trigger quality and make the skill harder to trust or maintain.";
}
if (check.category === "budget") {
return "Budget pressure matters because always-loaded or frequently-loaded text can make the workflow feel expensive fast.";
}
if (check.category === "measurement") {
return "Weak measurement means you are still steering with estimates instead of evidence.";
}
if (check.category === "best-practice") {
return "Best-practice gaps usually do not break the workflow immediately, but they make the skill harder to understand and improve.";
}
if (check.category === "complexity") {
return "Complexity findings matter because they increase review cost and make generated or helper code harder to change safely.";
}
if (check.category === "readability") {
return "Readability issues slow engineers down during review, debugging, and follow-up edits.";
}
if (check.category === "code-quality") {
return "Code-quality findings matter because helper scripts and supporting code are part of the user experience too.";
}
return "This finding affects confidence, clarity, or trust in the overall workflow.";
}
function buildDeductions(checks) {
return checks
.map((check) => ({
id: check.id,
category: check.category,
severity: check.severity,
status: check.status,
message: check.message,
penalty: computeCheckPenalty(check),
remediation: check.remediation,
source: check.source,
...(check.targetPath ? { targetPath: check.targetPath } : {}),
}))
.filter((entry) => entry.penalty > 0)
.sort((left, right) => {
if (right.penalty !== left.penalty) {
return right.penalty - left.penalty;
}
return left.id.localeCompare(right.id);
});
}
function buildCategoryDeductions(deductions) {
const totals = new Map();
for (const deduction of deductions) {
const current = totals.get(deduction.category) || {
category: deduction.category,
totalPenalty: 0,
checks: 0,
};
current.totalPenalty += deduction.penalty;
current.checks += 1;
totals.set(deduction.category, current);
}
return [...totals.values()].sort((left, right) => {
if (right.totalPenalty !== left.totalPenalty) {
return right.totalPenalty - left.totalPenalty;
}
return left.category.localeCompare(right.category);
});
}
function rankActionableChecks(checks) {
return checks
.filter((check) => check.status === "fail" || check.status === "warn")
.map((check) => ({
...check,
penalty: computeCheckPenalty(check),
why: deriveCheckWhy(check),
}))
.sort((left, right) => {
if (right.penalty !== left.penalty) {
return right.penalty - left.penalty;
}
if ((STATUS_PRIORITY[left.status] ?? 99) !== (STATUS_PRIORITY[right.status] ?? 99)) {
return (STATUS_PRIORITY[left.status] ?? 99) - (STATUS_PRIORITY[right.status] ?? 99);
}
if ((CATEGORY_PRIORITY[left.category] ?? 99) !== (CATEGORY_PRIORITY[right.category] ?? 99)) {
return (CATEGORY_PRIORITY[left.category] ?? 99) - (CATEGORY_PRIORITY[right.category] ?? 99);
}
return left.id.localeCompare(right.id);
});
}
function summarizeFinding(check) {
return {
id: check.id,
category: check.category,
severity: check.severity,
status: check.status,
message: check.message,
why: check.why,
remediation: check.remediation,
penalty: check.penalty,
source: check.source,
...(check.targetPath ? { targetPath: check.targetPath } : {}),
};
}
function buildWhyBullets(result, summary, failedErrors, warningSignals) {
const bullets = [];
if (failedErrors > 0) {
bullets.push(`${failedErrors} failing error check${failedErrors === 1 ? "" : "s"} are driving the highest-confidence problems.`);
}
if (warningSignals > 0) {
bullets.push(`${warningSignals} warning signal${warningSignals === 1 ? "" : "s"} still need cleanup before this feels polished.`);
}
if (summary.categoryDeductions.length > 0) {
const topCategory = summary.categoryDeductions[0];
bullets.push(`${topCategory.category} is the largest source of score loss at -${topCategory.totalPenalty} points.`);
}
if (
["heavy", "excessive"].includes(result.budgets?.trigger_cost_tokens?.band) ||
["heavy", "excessive"].includes(result.budgets?.invoke_cost_tokens?.band)
) {
bullets.push("Active budget pressure is high enough that token cost may dominate the user experience.");
} else {
bullets.push("Budget pressure is not the dominant issue right now.");
}
if (result.observedUsage?.sampleCount) {
bullets.push(`Observed usage is available from ${result.observedUsage.sampleCount} sample${result.observedUsage.sampleCount === 1 ? "" : "s"}.`);
} else {
bullets.push("No observed usage is attached yet, so budget conclusions are still based on static estimates.");
}
if (bullets.length === 0) {
bullets.push(`Current grade is ${summary.grade} with ${summary.riskLevel} reported risk.`);
}
return bullets.slice(0, 5);
}
function buildRiskReasons({ score, failedErrors, warningSignals, deductions, checkSummary }) {
const reasons = [];
if (failedErrors > 0) {
const examples = deductions
.filter((entry) => entry.status === "fail" && entry.severity === "error")
.slice(0, 3)
.map((entry) => entry.id);
reasons.push(
`Contains ${failedErrors} failing error check${failedErrors === 1 ? "" : "s"}${
examples.length > 0 ? ` (${examples.join(", ")})` : ""
}.`,
);
}
if (score < GRADE_THRESHOLDS.C) {
reasons.push(`Overall score is below ${GRADE_THRESHOLDS.C}, which the evaluator treats as high risk.`);
} else if (warningSignals > 0) {
reasons.push(
`Contains ${warningSignals} warning signal${warningSignals === 1 ? "" : "s"} that still need attention.`,
);
}
if (checkSummary.info > 0 && reasons.length === 0) {
reasons.push("No failing or warning checks were found; remaining items are informational only.");
}
if (reasons.length === 0) {
reasons.push("No failing error checks and no warning signals were found.");
}
return reasons;
}
export function computeSummary(result) {
const deductions = buildDeductions(result.checks);
const penalty = deductions.reduce((total, entry) => total + entry.penalty, 0);
const score = Math.max(0, Math.round(100 - penalty));
const grade =
score >= GRADE_THRESHOLDS.A
? "A"
: score >= GRADE_THRESHOLDS.B
? "B"
: score >= GRADE_THRESHOLDS.C
? "C"
: score >= GRADE_THRESHOLDS.D
? "D"
: "F";
const failedErrors = result.checks.filter(
(check) => check.status === "fail" && check.severity === "error",
).length;
const warningSignals = result.checks.filter((check) => check.status === "warn").length;
const riskLevel = failedErrors > 0 || score < 70 ? "high" : warningSignals > 0 || score < 85 ? "medium" : "low";
const checkCounts = summarizeChecks(result.checks);
const riskReasons = buildRiskReasons({
score,
failedErrors,
warningSignals,
deductions,
checkSummary: checkCounts,
});
const topRecommendations = unique(
result.checks
.filter((check) => check.status === "fail" || check.status === "warn")
.flatMap((check) => check.remediation)
.slice(0, 5),
);
return enrichSummary(result, {
score,
grade,
riskLevel,
riskReasons,
scoreBreakdown: {
startingScore: 100,
totalDeductions: penalty,
finalScore: score,
gradeThresholds: GRADE_THRESHOLDS,
},
checkCounts,
deductions,
categoryDeductions: buildCategoryDeductions(deductions),
topRecommendations,
});
}
export function enrichSummary(result, summary) {
const deductions = Array.isArray(summary?.deductions) ? summary.deductions : buildDeductions(result.checks);
const categoryDeductions = Array.isArray(summary?.categoryDeductions)
? summary.categoryDeductions
: buildCategoryDeductions(deductions);
const failedErrors = result.checks.filter(
(check) => check.status === "fail" && check.severity === "error",
).length;
const warningSignals = result.checks.filter((check) => check.status === "warn").length;
const actionableChecks = rankActionableChecks(result.checks).map(summarizeFinding);
const nextSummary = {
...summary,
deductions,
categoryDeductions,
};
return {
...nextSummary,
whyBullets:
Array.isArray(nextSummary.whyBullets) && nextSummary.whyBullets.length > 0
? nextSummary.whyBullets
: buildWhyBullets(result, { ...nextSummary, categoryDeductions }, failedErrors, warningSignals),
fixFirst:
Array.isArray(nextSummary.fixFirst) && nextSummary.fixFirst.length > 0
? nextSummary.fixFirst
: actionableChecks.slice(0, 3),
watchNext:
Array.isArray(nextSummary.watchNext) && nextSummary.watchNext.length > 0
? nextSummary.watchNext
: actionableChecks.slice(3, 6),
};
}